I let AI tag 296 bookmarks: 881 different tags, 724 used once

My take: AI tags describe each link, and a description sorts nothing. I sort by hand into one list and let search do the rest.
What to know
- Karakeep, formerly Hoarder, is a bookmark manager you host yourself (AGPL-3.0, 30,000 stars on GitHub on October 26, 2026). It can tag what you save on its own, with OpenAI or with a local model through Ollama.
- In my instance, measured on October 26, 2026: the 296 bookmarks I saved between December 16, 2024 and March 13, 2026 carry 1,397 tags, all set by the AI. They use 881 different names, and 724 of those names (82%) appear on a single bookmark.
- The same idea comes back under several names:
Self-Hostingtags 15 bookmarks,Self-Hosted10,self-hosted apps2,self_hosted_software1 andself-hosted application1.
What changes
A tag used once sorts nothing: to find a link again, Karakeep's full-text search does better. If you keep AI tagging, give it a vocabulary. Karakeep lets you add your own instructions to its tagging prompt (the request it sends the model), under User Settings, AI Settings, and its $tags placeholder passes along your existing tags: ask it to reuse them. For the bookmarks that matter, a list you fill yourself is the sorting that holds.
Drafted with Claude, Anthropic's AI, from my take. Reviewed and owned by me.